Ropy
September 9, 2003, 08:51 AM
//By Phil Hochmuth
The first court fine was issued in the SCO/IBM Linux legal saga
recently, but it wasn't in a U.S. court.
A court in Germany ruled that SCO must pay 10,000 Euros
($10,800) in damages for violating a German court's ruling that
SCO must cease claiming that the Linux source code violates its
intellectual property.
The ruling was made in a Munich court after a German Linux
advocacy group and a Germany-based Linux-focused IT integration
firm made the complaint about SCO's claims that Linux violated
SCO's intellectual property rights. The plaintiffs' main
complaint was that SCO had not come up with supporting evidence
to back up its claims.
As part of SCO's multibillion-dollar lawsuit against IBM, SCO
has made claims that Linux violates SCO's Unix intellectual
property rights, and that any Linux user may be in violation of
the law. The SCO suit alleges that IBM misused Unix code,
belonging to SCO, in its co-development of an enterprise Linux
kernel.
In June, the Munich court ruled, in basic terms, that SCO had to
put up, or shut up: either produce evidence to back up the
Linux/Unix intellectual property violations, or take down SCO's
German Web site that made the claims.
SCO complied, but a "Letter to SCO's Partners" warning of
potential legal issues around using Linux could still be viewed.
This prompted the fine by the court.
The injunction only keeps SCO from making Linux patent
infringement claims in Germany, but the ruling could be a
harbinger for the future of SCO's Linux patent lawsuit.
The first court fine was issued in the SCO/IBM Linux legal saga
recently, but it wasn't in a U.S. court.
A court in Germany ruled that SCO must pay 10,000 Euros
($10,800) in damages for violating a German court's ruling that
SCO must cease claiming that the Linux source code violates its
intellectual property.
The ruling was made in a Munich court after a German Linux
advocacy group and a Germany-based Linux-focused IT integration
firm made the complaint about SCO's claims that Linux violated
SCO's intellectual property rights. The plaintiffs' main
complaint was that SCO had not come up with supporting evidence
to back up its claims.
As part of SCO's multibillion-dollar lawsuit against IBM, SCO
has made claims that Linux violates SCO's Unix intellectual
property rights, and that any Linux user may be in violation of
the law. The SCO suit alleges that IBM misused Unix code,
belonging to SCO, in its co-development of an enterprise Linux
kernel.
In June, the Munich court ruled, in basic terms, that SCO had to
put up, or shut up: either produce evidence to back up the
Linux/Unix intellectual property violations, or take down SCO's
German Web site that made the claims.
SCO complied, but a "Letter to SCO's Partners" warning of
potential legal issues around using Linux could still be viewed.
This prompted the fine by the court.
The injunction only keeps SCO from making Linux patent
infringement claims in Germany, but the ruling could be a
harbinger for the future of SCO's Linux patent lawsuit.